SEOBy Marc Sanjuan11 Nov 20266 min read

How to know if your SEO is working and which metrics to ask your agency for

In short

To know if your SEO is working, check in Google Search Console whether clicks and impressions are rising for the searches you care about, compared with the same period the year before, and in Google Analytics whether more enquiries or sales are coming from organic search. The first changes usually show between 2 and 6 months. If your agency only shows you rankings for keywords nobody searches for, it is not telling you whether it works.

1 / 7The 4 figures that tell you if your SEO is working

You pay for SEO every month and they send you a report full of charts. But how do you know if your SEO is working for real? Here are the four figures that matter, where to see them for free, how long to wait and what to ask your agency so nobody sells you smoke.

The 4 figures that tell you if your SEO is working

ClicksSearch Console

Visits that come from Google. The main figure.

ImpressionsSearch Console

Times you appear in the results. They rise before clicks do.

Searches that matterSearch Console

Whether you appear for what you sell («plumber Mataró»), not just for your name.

Enquiries and salesAnalytics

Forms, calls or sales that come from organic search.

Average position and CTR help you understand why clicks change, but they are not the goal. The goal is more clients coming to you from Google.

Real exampleSEES ProductionAn editorial online presence for a high-end audiovisual production company.+140% time on siteSee the project →

How to check it yourself in 10 minutes

Google Search Console performance report showing clicks and impressions over time for a website
The Search Console performance report for UDB Sports, a site we handle SEO for: clicks and impressions month by month (figures hidden).
  1. Open Search ConsolePerformance → Search results. Turn on clicks, impressions and average position.
  2. Compare with the previous yearLast 3 months against the same 3 months last year. That removes the effect of seasonality.
  3. Filter out your brandRemove searches with your company name: those would arrive anyway without SEO.
  4. Look at the pagesWhich service pages are gaining clicks. That is where SEO is working.
  5. Cross-check with AnalyticsEnquiries or sales from the «Organic Search» channel in the same period.

If you do not have access to your Search Console, ask for it today. It is yours, even if your agency set it up.

How long SEO takes to show

2-6 monthsfirst changes in impressions and clicks, depending on your starting point
6-12 monthsstable results for competitive searches
Diagram of an AI assistant answering a question by recommending a business
When someone asks an AI assistant for a recommendation, the answer names specific businesses: the goal is to be one of them.

A new website or a very competitive sector takes longer. A website that has been around for years and has technical errors that get fixed can climb in weeks. We explain it with cases in how long a website takes to rank.

Which metrics to ask your SEO agency for

A good monthly report fits on one page and answers three questions: what has happened, why, and what you will do next month.

  1. Search Console clicks and impressions, without your brand, compared with the previous year.
  2. Target searches: the ones you agreed at the start, with their position and clicks.
  3. Pages that grow and drop the most, with the reason.
  4. Enquiries or sales coming from organic search.
  5. Work done that month: pages created, technical improvements, links earned.
  6. Plan for the following month, with priorities.
Razol ParquetA real case+85%organic traffic in 6 monthsRazol Parquet · See the project →

Signs that your SEO is not going well

  • They only show you rankings for keywords nobody searches for or that only include your brand.
  • You have no access to Search Console or Analytics.
  • They guarantee you first place. Nobody can guarantee it.
  • Months go by and you do not know what has been done.
  • They buy links in bulk or publish unreviewed copy to «climb fast».
  • They talk about «visibility» or «authority» but never about clicks or enquiries.

Why invest in SEO, if it works

Because you do not pay for the clicks. Once a page is at the top, it brings visits every day even if you stop investing for a while, unlike ads. That is why it pays to measure it properly: it is an investment that builds up.

Frequently asked questions on a restaurant website, collapsible, with links to the other language versions
The FAQ on a BarK page: where it is, whether to book, the average price… short answers that customers and search engines both read.

If you are looking for someone to do it, you will find what to ask in the best SEO agencies in Barcelona and real prices in how much SEO costs in Barcelona. And how we work, at our SEO agency in Barcelona.

We'll send you our next SEO guide

What's changing in Google and what works for our clients, explained for small businesses. No spam.

Guides for your business, in your inbox

What we publish on websites, SEO, ads and AI for small businesses. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know if my SEO is working?

Check in Search Console whether clicks and impressions are rising for the searches you care about (without your brand) against the same period the year before, and in Analytics whether more enquiries are coming from organic search.

How long does SEO take to show?

The first changes usually show between 2 and 6 months, and stable results for competitive searches between 6 and 12.

Which metrics should I ask my SEO agency for?

Non-brand clicks and impressions compared with the previous year, how the target searches are evolving, the pages that rise and fall, enquiries from organic, the work done and the plan for the following month.

Is climbing in rankings a good sign?

Only if they are searches people actually make and that bring clients. Climbing for keywords with no searches or with your brand says nothing.

How do I choose an SEO agency?

It should give you access to your data, report on clicks and enquiries, explain what it does each month, not guarantee you first place and not lock you into a minimum term.

Why invest in SEO?

Because you do not pay for the clicks: a well-ranked page brings visits every day for a long time, unlike ads.

Keep reading

Want to know how your SEO is doing?

We review your Search Console and your website for free and tell you what works, what does not and what we would change first.

Written byMarc SanjuanFounder of GNERAIA question about the article? Message us

You may also like

See all articles

Tell us about your project.

We reply in under 24 hours with a concrete proposal.

★★★★★
“Precio ajustado y se adaptan a las necesidades del cliente. Totalmente recomendable.”
Joan · Review on Google ↗
What do you need?
We reply in under 24 hours.

Rather not fill anything in?WhatsAppinfo@gnerai.com

Data protection. Controller: GNERAI. Purpose: to reply to your message. Legal basis: pre-contractual steps at your request. Recipients: we do not share your data; it is only processed by the providers who work for us. Rights: access, rectification, erasure and others at info@gnerai.com. More information in our privacy policy.